old friends and new - echoes of wishes
The nature of these two wishes, paired in this moment, was tragedy. Not because of the desires expressed, but rather, the fulfillment of them together.
Zoey, first. A snippet of knowledge was granted to her. Immortality, of a sort: the type that Juggernaut knew, would be given to her. Not infinite, not yet. Perhaps if she chose so, should she die and be resurrected--no,
reprinted--as intended: a copy of the Zoey of here and now--then she could Iterate further. But from here, no further experiences that she gained would be added to this memory. She had been stored, uploaded, a magic scan of her mind and being--experiences and
current memory--laid within the Hive in the form of a single Clearstone. Not even Mother knew quite where this stone was, not yet. This was to prevent tampering. An early resurrection. No: this was one embedded deep within the dark halls of an unused tunnel, to be brought to light if and when Zoey died.
But that Zoey would be a travesty, and she'd know that now: lacking the memories her Key had kept safe for her; missing any experiences between now and her death. A snapshot, not a copy. An impression of her. It was something, but it was not and never would be
her. Still... perhaps within the Hive, a
version of Zoey could do some good.
...A truth now passed on to Juggernaut, as his consciousness faded from this plane. The visions that followed seemed to last long minutes, but in truth, passed in merely seconds.
He was frozen in time, peering into a finely appointed parlor. Two men in suits sat on comfortable chairs before a fire, pipes at the ready, drinks in tumblers on small tables at their sides. The stuffed head of a deer was mounted above that roaring fireplace, and thick rugs and a smoky interior placed this--though Juggernaut could not know this--quite some time before "doritos" in Earth's history.
"Have you heard of Theseus's Paradox?" asked the first man, sitting back and tapping his pipe.
"I have not?" said the second, sipping from his drink just after.
"They say that the Athenians commemorated Theseus's escape from Athens by taking his ship on its old journey every year. Consider this ship: ancient, in need of repairs, naturally."
"Naturally."
"Each year the sails are replaced, as one would expect. But in time so must the aging mast, and the rotting deck-boards. In time the planking of its sides, the cladding, the prow and its figurehead. Now imagine," the man continued, taking a long mouthful of pipe-smoke, puffing it out again,
"that all the pieces have been replaced. The paradox asks, is it the same ship?"
The second man thought about this, and scoffed.
"Of course. It still bears the name, doesn't it? And it is more about the purpose of the thing, after all."
The first man smiled.
"You always have been a practical sort, John, but then consider Hobbes' addition to the question. Let us say a dock-worker kept all of the replaced pieces: the original sails and rotten mast, the old figurehead... And in time they are put back together to make a second ship. Is that not, now, the true Ship of Theseus? And then, what of the first... the one of replaced parts?"
John frowned, thinking with furrowed brow.
"You know I'm a practical sort, yes, so I suppose you know my answer? One is simply the original and no longer functional. The second is the ship as pertains to shipping lanes and berths and the like."
The first man laughed delightedly.
"It is good to see a strong mind with simple answers tackling these questions. Now, what if that dockworker loved this ship dearly? Loved it for what it was," and here this man turned,
looking directly at Juggernaut; "what if he adored every broken plank and moth-eaten sail? What if he cared for them, maintaining them as best he could and then one day, his old vessel--filled with his longstanding love for it--was gone from its dock, and replaced with the second, newer vessel? How would he feel, do you think? After all, that original is one-of-a-kind, and now it is gone forever..."
His voice trailed off, as did his face, and John's, and the parlor, swirling into gray nothing. From that gray nothing came a march of Drones, of Hive, moving through an icy tunnel. They were Juggernaut's allies: Ananke and Pallas, Ace and Siren and Orthus and Scorn and Elysium and Alcina-... but
none of them were them. They were copies. Reprints. Ships with parts all replaced. As the second man had said: for practical purposes they were the same.
Yet Juggernaut would be granted this knowledge, here and now: the knowledge of Hive's lie. They
were not the same. They were assembled of other parts and pieces. Granted a mere
copy of memory.
That which was beloved in them, loved... they could imitate it. They could even--truly and honestly--embrace it, and be much like the original. But
the originals were dead. And they would never be coming back.
...Perhaps he knew this already. Perhaps none of this was new knowledge, shocking in its revelation. Maybe he'd already come to terms with it.
But what did it mean, that he had just inflicted this upon Zoey?
And he had; and he would know this.
...Ahh, but it was not finished.
Not quite yet. A final little whisper through his consciousness, and he saw a thousand unnamed, intimate moments of friendship between a thousand sentient creatures. Gembounds and Drones, Valkhounds and creatures from beyond any nests or caves. Each time they met it was like a light igniting, gently changing those whom they met, spreading in blinking and tenuous bonds throughout the cosmos.
Each of those rotten ships, doomed to sink and be discarded, were nonetheless
remembered and
beloved. Each light, carried and passed on to another. That was, as Zoey tried to Wish him to understand, a bittersweet beauty of reality: that all things were ephemereal. They came and went and were beloved and were lost. That was their value: their unique nature, one of a kind and then gone forever. They were beloved for who they were, by those who held those lights with them.
And Zoey saw that value within him. He had lit within her a glimmering little light that she carried, and he would not be forgotten.
Zoey is given a single revival, after death, into the Hive. Should she die, she will be reborn as a Clearstone drone within Ursa's hive. She will only have the memories that she bore as of this moment in this thread.
Juggernaut has been given a vision of a philosophical discussion.